The Beemer I think would be more suitable for your style of riding and needs. My concern would be the servicing and parts cost, but at least, well, I hope, the build quality and reliability would be much better than the Aprillia. You have had good experience with the Beemers before too.
Multistarada defo suits your style but yet again servicing, parts and reliability thoughthe reliability is supposed to be a bit better on the duke these days. Duke

how about a superduke.
Personally I think the Tuano's are ugly but's personal preference.
apart from the lack of wind protectio
Now the RC8 is something else
Good to hear you will be back on two wheels again mate.
Argh good call on the Yamaha Jamie and you beat be to the superduke.
(:-})